Writer/director Damian McCarthy continues his pursuit of elevating horror beyond surface-level scares. His intention is clear: to explore the psychological and emotional weight behind fear, using supernatural elements as a lens to examine guilt, trauma, and the human need for redemption. It is an ambitious goal, and one that shows glimpses of depth throughout the film.
At the centre of Hokum is John Bauman (Scott), a man attempting to navigate the weight of a past tragedy that continues to shape his present. Drawn into a remote and eerie Irish setting, he is forced to confront both external threats and the internal consequences of his past decisions. As the supernatural elements begin to intensify, the lines between reality and memory blur, leading him into a confrontation not only with what surrounds him—but with who he has become.
For horror fans, there is much to engage with. The film builds a sense of unease through its setting and pacing, drawing viewers into its bleak and isolating world. However, as the narrative unfolds, it begins to rely more heavily on familiar genre conventions. What initially feels layered and intriguing gradually gives way to predictable ghost story tropes, which can lessen the emotional impact. Even so, McCarthy’s story is not without value. Beneath the surface lies a story wrestling with themes of death, forgiveness, and the longing for redemption. These elements linger beyond the film’s scares, prompting audiences to reflect on how people deal with guilt and whether reconciliation is ever truly possible. It is here that McCarthy’s vision for something deeper within the genre is most evident.
Ultimately, Hokum is a film that may be appreciated more than fully enjoyed. Its ambition to say something meaningful within the horror space is commendable, even if its execution does not always match its intent. For genre enthusiasts, it may prove rewarding; for others, it may feel uneven, yet still thought-provoking.
REEL DIALOGUE: The deeper redemption
At the heart of Hokum is a man burdened by his past. John Bauman’s journey reflects a deep need for forgiveness—for a tragedy that has shaped every part of his life, relationships, and sense of self. His struggle raises a question many of us face: can we truly move beyond the weight of our past?
While the film offers its own interpretation, the Bible speaks to a greater story of redemption—one that extends beyond what we can achieve on our own. It reveals that Jesus came into the world to rescue humanity from sin and restore us to a relationship with God.
For those seeking to understand this more fully, one of the Gospel accounts is a powerful place to begin—exploring who Jesus is and why His life, death, and resurrection matter.
“For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life.” — John 3:16